Do The Thrashers Have Large Talons?

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Last Home Game for Marian Hossa?

I'm not going to lie to anyone. I'm about as depressed as a person can be going to the Thrashers game tonight because I fully expect this the last time I'll see Marian Hossa in a Thrashers uniform.

Yes, he's had a sub-par season by his own standards this year, but I have tremendous respect for the way he played in his first two seasons here. Hossa was an absolute game breaker and probably our best defensive forward. That is a VERY difficult feat to accomplish. Seldom do you see a top ten scorer in the NHL back check the way Hossa has here in Atlanta. God's honest truth is that if Hossa had turned in those exact two seasons--but did it in New York or Canada--he would have gotten more MVP votes (I'm not saying he would have won, but he would certainly would have been mentioned much more often). It is a shame that those two season brought this organization so little and that his hard work failed to get the attention it deserved.

Hossa arrived here in one of Don Waddell's more inspired moves in exchange for Heatley who was viewed (by some at least) as damaged goods and a big question mark. When you look at how little the Oilers got in return for Chris Pronger you can see that it is not easy trading a star level player and getting good value in return. But here we are at the end of Hossa's three year deal and all indications are that he will not re-sign here because he doesn't expect there to be any Stanley Cup parades in the next five years. Honestly, I think the same thing.

The Thrashers defense is a mess and pretty much always has been. The goaltender is young and shows promise, but he is inconsistent and can't be counted on to play great in net for four playoff rounds. The forwards are a mish-mash of expensive wingers, overpaid checkers, older players heading into their decline years and smallish centers who will be pushed around in the playoffs when things get physical. (Can you imagine the Thrashers winning any games against the Ducks or Flames--I can't after watching the way those two teams went after Detroit in the playoffs last spring.) The ownership is very unsettled. In the final analysis the Thrashers have some interesting pieces that could become part of a Stanley Cup contender but right now there are more pieces missing than in place.

And yet the Thrashers remain the playoff hunt because they are fortunate enough to play in the worst division in hockey where not one team out of five can get their act together long enough to pull away. The only reason the Thrashers are still in the playoffs is because they are lucky. Talking about "the guys battling" or "they're really hanging in there" just obscures the hard truth: this is just not a very good hockey club.

In some ways I really hate the three division system because it allows fans, owners and management to trick themselves into thinking this team is really better than it is. If the NHL used a two division system we couldn't avoid coming to the obvious conclusion that this team is not very good and unlikely to go anywhere without very significant upgrades at center and defense.

But Hossa isn't going to deceive himself and why should he? If he stays healthy he probably has 5 quality season left in his body. Why waste those on a club that can't seem to ever identify or acquire quality defensemen? (or at least more than one every three years, Havelid and Enstrom could play on any team in the NHL.) Why sign a contract and hope that you get into the playoffs when you could sign with a club that has a Hall of Fame goalie or Hall of Fame defenseman behind you? The Thrashers have a potential Hall of Fame winger who is beginning to exert himself on the defensive end and show leadership qualities for the first time in his career.

Hossa has options and if I were him I'd give free agency a try too. The last time he signed a contract he was traded 10 minutes later. The same guy offering him a contract today was the guy who snatched him away from Ottawa. That might lead to some trust issues if it happened to you.

Sorry to be such a downer today, but that is where I'm at. I'm tired of missing the playoffs almost every year. I'm tired of watching the other team celebrate after yet another appalling defensive breakdown. I'm tired of only see bits and pieces of a contending team out there on the ice. But mostly I'm weary because I expect the Thrashers to have one less quality piece when I step into Philips Arena on February 28th.

Real Eastern Conference Standings 2-13
Points above .500
1. +15 Ottawa
2. +13 Pittsburgh
3. +10 Montreal
4. +10 New Jersey
5. +9 Philadelphia
6. +6 Buffalo
7. +4 Rangers
8. +5 Boston
9. +2 Washington
10 +1 Carolina
11 +0 Atlanta
12 +0 Islanders
13 -1 Florida
14 -2 Toronto
15 -3 Tampa


  • If you're feeling depressed about Hossa, well, you've got good reason for it! Hossa's heart really isn't in Atlanta, I don't think. He hasn't shown the spunk this year that he used to. When was the last time you saw him drop his shoulder and muscle his way in? He plays like he's trying to not get hurt so that he can get a better offer from somewhere else. He didn't come here by choice (you mentioned that he got traded 10 minutes after signing with Ottawa) so this wasn't his preference in the first place. I agree with you. He won't be here next season.

    Waddell may just let him finish it out here without trading him at all. Would you want to be known as the GM who "got rid" of Hossa? I wouldn't. I hope that the club can pick some more solid defensemen and strong centers soon. We've got lots of offensive talent. Now we need some muscle at the blueline. If someone would crash the net once in a while, that wouldn't hurt either. Keep up the good work on your blog!

    By Blogger diegohall, at 5:02 PM  

  • Diegohall,

    I'd rather be known as the GM who got rid of Hossa than the GM who let him walk for nothing. At least if he trades him we might be able to fill one or two of our gaps.

    By Anonymous silverpork, at 7:27 PM  

  • I know his stats are not as good as last year, but he has been playing better as of late. He has 53 points right now; 26 goals and 27 assists. I could see him getting around 75-76 points with at least 30-33 goals. That is still respectable. Perrin even said that Hossa is ignoring a lot of the trade talk and is having fun and playing his game which I agree with. I think that if we are going to make a move with Hossa, then we should get another good defenseman like Komisarek from Montreal, Kronwall from Detroit, or someone else of a good caliber that is close to Hossa's age with enough youth but experience where his impact will be felt immediately.

    I agree with your assessments of Zhitnik; he is awful. He scored a goal in a recent game, but his response and quickness to the puck is terrible!!! They need to not resign him or trade him; although, who would really want him? I know I wouldn't. Losing Coburn was a big mistake.

    By Anonymous SteveS, at 11:40 AM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

Who links to my website?
View My Stats