Do The Thrashers Have Large Talons?

Sunday, April 22, 2007

The Puzzle of Jim Slater

So I'm starting to think about the off-season and give some thought as to what the 2007 Thrashers team might look like. I'm plugging some salary numbers into my handy Excel spreadsheet and making estimates about how much money certain players will receive and I get to Jim Slater.

Slater was a very late 1st round pick and signed an entry level contract that pays him close to the maximum allowed for an entry level contract. This summer Slater will be a restricted free agent which essentially means that as long as the Thrashers make him a qualifying offer he is extremely likely to sign a deal with Atlanta.

Slater currently makes $900,000 a year according to Irish Blues exhaustive salary website. The Thrashers qualifying offer has to include a 5% raise. The team must send Slater a written offer for a contract with a salary of 945,000 in order to qualify him. Slater can decline the offer or sign it (If he declines it the Thrashers retain their right to match any offers made to him by another team.) But the problem is that he will be way overpaid at $945,000 a year.

Using Irish Blues NHL salary data I collected together a list of all NHL forwards making between 1 million and 800,000--players who make about the same amount of money as Slater (and were regular NHLers--minor league prospects were excluded). I came up with 39 players in Slater's salary neighborhood and then looked at their points-per-game. Jim Slater is right down the bottom of the list of comparables. I have him ranked 33 out of 39 just behind Patrik Stefan's .268 PPG and just above Brian Sutherby's .246 PPG. To be perfectly honest Slater is getting paid nearly $1 million a year because of where he was selected in the draft rather than his NHL performance.

So if you're the Thrashers is it worth it? Do you make him a qualifying offer that pays him double what he is worth or do you let him walk? Slater was in effect a checking line player most of the year making twice as much money as most checkers (who often make around the NHL minimum of $450,000). Is Slater really equal to Vigier and Larsen combined?

Slater has great speed but very poor balance. I can't think of a NHL player who falls over every single game like Jim does. He is fast but lacks lateral quickness because of his balance issues and thus he is not used as penalty killer. He doesn't score all that much. In the playoffs he centered our 4th line. Can this team afford a $1 million 4th line guy?

Now you might say that Slater was poorly used and he has the potential to do more, and I would probably agree with that statement. But Bob Hartley is coming back as coach I have no reason to think he will used in a significantly different fashion in the coming season. After all the Thrashers had a gaping hole at center all year and Hartley never gave him more than occasional chances to show what he could do. If DW signs some more centers I can see Slater being buried on the 4th line all next season.

The harsh reality is that in a salary cap league every dollar you overpay for a player is a dollar wasted and the Thrasher wasted their money on Slater last year. He gave them nothing that a 500,000 checker couldn't have provided. Two years ago the Thrashers faced a similar problem when Stefan's contract expired. Stefan ended up taking a slight pay cut in exchange for a two-year deal. To put it nicely, that didn't work out very well. The team would have been better off to let him walk and spend that money on a cheaper more effective guy.

Personally I'm much rather see those dollars go towards resigning Pascal Dupuis who was a solid PK guy, crash line member and even got some PP time late in the playoffs. I'd rather see those dollars go towards bringing Jon Sim back for another season. But the team found it hard to give up on a former 1st rounder last time and I doubt we will see them let Slater depart for nothing either. Slater probably has more upside than Stefan did, but it still requires a bit of "wish-casting" (as opposed to "forecasting") to justify his salary requirements.


  • Great analysis. I hope MGT thinks about next season the way you have done.

    By Blogger Mike Burke, at 5:26 PM  

  • After contributing solidly last year, Slater seemed just all over the map this year. I always hoped he would settle down, ramp down the speed a tad in exchange for control, but that didn't happen. I agree -- I'd much rather see Dupuis and Sim back. But it's a shame that last year's promise couldn't be fulfilled.

    By Blogger Carole, at 9:08 PM  

  • Maybe the Spirit can hire him for team mascot. He just didn't produce. See ya.

    By Blogger Vladimir, at 3:14 AM  

  • Excellent Title for this one...

    I was puzzled by Jim's lack of performance this year as well. I'm guessing we won't resign him (although we keep resigning Sutton :)) and he'll have a 30 goal season for someone else.

    I'd say we have to look at what his potential this coming season is. Is he more likely to play like he did in season 1 or season 2? Was it truly a sophomore slump or was it something bigger.

    I'd love to see him on the team next year, but (you are completely right) a million bucks can get some one better than season 2 jim slater.

    By Blogger Dave, at 7:26 AM  

  • Very good analysis. Clearly, he is not worth $1million dollars. Who is to say that if we don't ign him for that ammount that another team will offer him any more than the minimum. Spending that money on Dupuis and Bellanger is a much more effective allocation of assets.

    Once we call the kids from Chicago up, they will require some ice time that Slater would eat into as a veteran. I would rather take my chances with those guys than the known quantity of Slater, even if it is season 1 Jim, as opposed to this past season.

    I just read that Nashville will not re-sign Timonen. Now, this past year DeVries made 2.2 million and Sutton 1.9- Timonen made 2.3 million. I say don't resign either of these guys and give the 31 year old Timonen a 3 year deal at 8.5 million. He was plus 20 last season and actually scored from the blue line, 55 points- more than the two of them combined.

    By Blogger Benjamin, at 10:36 AM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

Who links to my website?
View My Stats