Do The Thrashers Have Large Talons?

Saturday, February 24, 2007

Is the Defense Better or Worse than Last Season?

There was some talk over on the blog about our defensemen. I certainly was one of those people who figured the team's defense would be better after Modry was replaced by Vishnevsky and McCarthy. But let's take a quick look to see if that is supported by the numbers.

First, how is ATL doing at preventing goals? This season ATL ranks just 23rd in GAA, but the previous season we were 24th, so there is essentially no change in our ranking. (I look at the rankings because it is an easy way to control for the fact that league offense varies from year to year. Ranking allow us to see how ATL stacks up to the competition in each category.)

What is going on with the goaltending and defense?

If we look at shots on goal against (SOGA) it gives us an indication of how well the skaters (especially the defense) are doing in terms of either preventing shots or blocking them. Last year ATL ranked 18th out of 30 teams and this season they rank just 23rd out of 30 teams so there has been a decline relative to the rest of the NHL in terms of allowing shots against.

On the other hand if we look at team's goaltenders we see that the team save percentage (SV%) has jumped up from 24th last season to 17th this season. So there has been an improvement in keeping those SOG out of the net.

Summary: The goaltending has improved over last season (how could it not) but all of the gains in netminding have been lost by a decline in shot prevention by the skaters. The net effect is a wash and the team is still among the worst in the NHL in terms of team defense.

This confirms my impression that the talent level on this club is such that while I consider ATL a playoff team, they are not a Stanley Cup contender baring divine intervention. The defensemen are simply below average and I can't imagine them making it through multiple rounds of the playoffs without making critical mental errors that will cost the team games.


  • It would be interesting to see where ATL ranked on shots-blocked prior to Sutton's injury. Before he went down, he was 2nd or 3rd in the league in blocked shots.

    I've said this before - I think Havelid was one of the most important signings we made during the offseason, but he is really a 2nd line guy on most teams (3rd in some cases). I got a chuckle at DW's comments a couple of months back when he said we had depth on the blue line. Ummm, yeah, just because you have seven healthy d-men doesn't mean you have depth.

    By Anonymous silverpork, at 11:37 AM  

  • Well, now we add Zhitnik to the D-line. How much kick do you think that will give?

    By Blogger Dave, at 11:59 PM  

  • Well, now we've added Zhitnik to the mix. What are your thoughts on this short term and long term (giving up Coburn)?

    By Blogger Dave, at 12:01 AM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

Who links to my website?
View My Stats